Toyota Priuses Head-to-Head: Prime vs AWD-e

Prime vs AWD-e

2021 Toyota Prius Prime Limited (left) vs 2021 Toyota Prius XLE AWD-e

With hybrid vehicles of all sorts now commonplace in the American new-vehicle market, the Toyota Prius doesn’t get the respect (or sales numbers) it once did. These days, most major manufacturers offer numerous hybrids, plug-in hybrids, or both—and increasingly, these hybrids are versions of regular-line vehicles, not stand-alone, hybrid-only models. The majority are also SUVs—the type of everyday family vehicle American buyers are choosing in greater numbers than 4-door sedans of any stripe.

Still, the Prius has a lot to offer, in addition to the obvious benefits of its standout fuel economy. Considering its compact-car footprint, it provides respectable room for adults in both the front and rear seats, and its hatchback-sedan layout improves its cargo-hauling versatility over a traditional 4-door sedan. In any of its forms, the Prius is no performance machine. The suspension and steering are set up for everyday commuting, not enthusiastic cornering. Acceleration is a bit tepid compared to the average new vehicle, particularly in highway driving. But as an around-town commuter, it keeps up with the flow of traffic just fine—thanks in part to the immediate response of its electric motor(s).

And, the Prius comes in multiple flavors that make it more attractive to buyers with specific wants and needs. The current generation of the Prius debuted for 2016, and the Prius Prime plug-in-hybrid version was added for 2017. All-wheel-drive Prius “AWD-e” models followed for 2019.

The larger battery in Prius Prime models enables them to offer an estimated 25 miles of pure-electric driving—enough range for gas-free daily commuting for many Americans. And when its plug-in battery charge is used up, the Prime simply switches to normal gas/electric-hybrid operation like other Priuses. So, long road trips are no problem—no range anxiety or concerns about finding a charging station.

The Prius AWD-e models add an electric motor to power the rear wheels, to deliver improved traction in slippery and/or snowy conditions—just the ticket for eco-conscious buyers in cold-weather or high-altitude climes. The motor always powers the rear wheels when accelerating from a stop up to 6 mph, then disengages unless wheel slip is detected, in which case it powers them up to 43 mph. This allows for a “boost” at launch while shutting off the motor when it’s not needed in order to improve fuel economy.

We tested both a Prius Prime Limited and a Prius XLE AWD-e and decided to line them up head-to-head to see how they compare. Check out our pics below, as well as our observed fuel economy, optional-equipment lists, and report-card info on our two test cars.

You’ll pay more, of course, for the added functionality of either the powertrain or the plug-in-hybrid powertrains—and the latter commands the larger price premium.  Our Prime test vehicle was about $3600 more than our AWD-e tester, but most of that gap is attributed to the up-level equipment of the Prime’s top-line Limited trim (a trim level that the AWD-e does not offer). Though the equipment levels don’t line up exactly, the base-price gap drops to about $1100 when comparing the Prime and AWD-e LE models (the base trim level for both) and just $425 when comparing XLE models.

Test Drive: 2020 Toyota Prius Limited

Prime vs AWD-e

Prius vs. Prius

Prius vs. Prius

Prius vs. Prius

The Prius Prime gets a slightly more aggressive look via quad LED headlights and a blacked-out, inset front-fascia design.

Test Drive: 2021 Honda Accord Hybrid Touring

Prius vs. Prius

The Prius Prime’s rear end styling is a bit swoopier as well. It’s highlighted by an unusual compound-curve rear window (which thankfully doesn’t affect the view astern) and a sleek-looking full-width taillight arrangement.

Quick Spin: 2020 Toyota Corolla Hybrid LE

Prius vs. Prius

Both the Prime and regular Prius models have an unusual vertical “mini-window” beneath the main rear window. This provides a bit of extra rear visibility, but the large crossbar splitting the view can be disorienting.

First Spin: 2021 Toyota Camry

Prius vs. Prius

Not much different here, in terms of visuals or horsepower. Both the Prime and the AWD-e have the same 121-hp 4-cylinder hybrid powertrain, but the Prime feels a bit zippier overall.

Test Drive: 2021 Toyota Venza XLE

Prius vs. Prius

A vertically oriented 11.6-inch touchscreen is standard equipment on Prius Prime XLE and Limited models, but it’s unavailable on the Prius AWD-e. The plus-size screen is able to display multiple readouts—such as the navigation-system map and hybrid power-flow readings—at the same time, a nice feature.

Quick Spin: 2021 BMW 330e

Prius vs. Prius

Here’s a subtle but significant downside to the Prius Prime—in order provide space for the larger battery pack, the Prime’s rear cargo floor is raised by a couple inches over the non-plug-in Prius versions. That doesn’t sound like a lot, but it reduces the Prime’s cargo capacity more than you might think—there’s 19.8 cubic feet of room behind the rear seats, compared to 27.4 cubic feet in the AWD-e (which offers the same cargo capacity as the front-wheel-drive Prius). That can be the difference between a large box or other cargo item fitting, or not fitting.

Test Drive: 2021 Mini Cooper SE Countryman ALL4 PHEV


2021 Toyota Prius Prime Limited

Prius Prime

2021 Toyota Prius Prime Limited in Blue Magnetism

Class: Compact Car

Miles driven: 229

Fuel used: 2.3 gallons

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort B-
Power and Performance C+
Fit and Finish B+
Fuel Economy A+
Value A-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy B-
Tall Guy B
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 121-hp 1.8-liter
Engine Type 4-cylinder plug-in hybrid
Transmission CVT automatic
Drive Wheels front

Real-world fuel economy: 99.5 mpg

Driving mix: 70% city, 30% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 54 mpg/133 MPGe (both in combined city/hwy driving)

Fuel type: Regular gas

Base price: $34,000 (not including $995 destination charge)

Options on test vehicle: Carpet mat package ($259), door edge guards ($125), rear bumper applique ($79), illuminated door sills ($299)

Price as tested: $35,757

Quick Hits

The great: Outstanding fuel economy with pure-electric capability on short trips

The good: Around-town throttle response, ride quality, cargo space and versatility, relatively affordable pricing

The not so good: Not all drivers like unconventional control layout, limited highway-speed merging and passing power, larger battery compromises cargo-hauling capacity

More Prius price and availability information


2021 Toyota Prius XLE AWD-e

Prius AWD-e

2021 Toyota Prius XLE AWD-e in Magnetic Gray Metallic

Class: Compact Car

Miles driven: 442

Fuel used: 8.8 gallons

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort B-
Power and Performance C+
Fit and Finish B
Fuel Economy A+
Value A-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy B-
Tall Guy B
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 121-hp 1.8-liter
Engine Type 4-cylinder hybrid
Transmission CVT automatic
Drive Wheels AWD

Real-world fuel economy: 50.2 mpg

Driving mix: 55% city, 45% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 51/47/49 (mpg city, highway, combined)

Fuel type: Regular gas

Base price: $29,575 (not including $995 destination charge)

Options on test vehicle: Advanced Technology Package ($800), carpet floor mats/carpet cargo mat ($259), door edge guards ($125), rear bumper applique ($69), cargo net ($49), illuminated door sills ($299)

Price as tested: $32,171

Quick Hits

The great: Outstanding fuel economy with all-weather traction of all-wheel drive

The good: Around-town throttle response, ride quality, cargo space and versatility

The not so good: Not all drivers like unconventional control layout, limited highway-speed merging and passing power


Follow Damon on Twitter

Check out the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

2021 Prime vs AWD-e Gallery

(Click below for enlarged images)

Prime vs AWD-e

5 Ways Hybrids are Different

Prime vs AWD-e

For GREAT deals on a new or used Nissan check out Mossy Nissan Oceanside TODAY!

Quick Spin: 2021 Toyota Tundra TRD Pro

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD Pro

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD Pro in Lunar Rock

Quick Spin, Consumer Guide

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD Pro CrewMax

Class: Large Pickup

Miles Driven: 351

Fuel Used: 27.4 gallons

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort A-
Power and Performance B+
Fit and Finish B-
Fuel Economy D
Value B-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy A
Tall Guy A
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 381-hp 5.7L
Engine Type V8
Transmission 6-speed automatic
Drive Wheels 4WD

Real-world fuel economy: 12.8 mpg

Driving mix: 55% city, 45% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 13/17/14 (city, highway, combined)

Fuel type: Regular gasoline

Base price: $53,050 (not including $1395 destination charge)

Options on test car: Spray-on bedliner ($579)

Price as tested: $55,224

Quick Hits

The great: Build quality; cavernous cabin provides ample passenger room and storage space

The good: Smooth power delivery; simple, straightforward controls; distinctive TRD Pro styling touches

The not so good: “Trucky” ride quality; lousy fuel economy, even for the class; lacks most of the high-tech available features of domestic-brand rivals

More Tundra price and availability information

CG Says:

If you had to guess, would you say Lunar Rock is:

  1. Impossible to hear in the airless void of space.
  2. A Toyota paint color.
  3. All of the above.
Toyota Tundra TRD Pro

The TRD Pro sits at the top of the Tundra model lineup, alongside the ritzy Platinum and 1794 trim levels. Debossed “TRD PRO” lettering in the bed sides and an extra-burbly TRD dual-exhaust system are among the standard features.

Of course, the correct answer is “C.” As for the paint, you can find it on the Tundra TRD Pro, the most-off-road-ready large pickup currently in Toyota showrooms. The almost-pastel grayish green replaces Army Green as a TRD Pro color choice—and that’s about the biggest change (aside from a little boost in price) that’s been made to the 2021 model.

Test Drive: 2021 Ford F-150 PowerBoost Hybrid

Toyota Tundra TRD Pro

The Tundra’s dashboard layout is really showing its age compared to the newer designs of the rest of the large pickup category, but the controls are simple and straightforward, and the cabin’s build quality is high.

The Tundra went Pro in 2014, sat out the 2018 season, then returned rejuvenated to the lineup for ’19. Its key external features include a raised suspension with specially tuned Fox shock absorbers with remote fluid reservoirs for the rear units, TRD dual exhaust and front skid plate, 18-inch BBS forged-aluminum black-finish wheels, LED fog lights, blacked-out Toyota-label grille, and “TRD PRO” debossing on the bed sides. The interior contains leather-trimmed front bucket seats with TRD Pro identification sewn into the backs and red contrast stitching.

Both of the Tundra’s 4-door cab styles are available for the TRD Pro: The roomier CrewMax with 5.5-foot-long cargo bed and the Double Cab that trades some rear-seat space for a 6.5-foot bed. Consumer Guide tested a CrewMax that starts at $54,645 with delivery. (The Double Cab sells for $4275 less.) Only the addition of a spray-on bedliner pushed the total to $55,224.

Test Drive: 2021 Ram 1500 TRX

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD

There’s ample front-seat space in any Tundra, and the CrewMax extra-long crew-cab body style offers excellent rear legroom. TRD Pros get leather upholstery with red contrast stitching and embroidered TRD Pro logos on the front seats.

CrewMax passenger room is abundant in both rows, and the back seat easily hosts three adults. Step-in is fairly high, and without running boards or step rails that might interfere with operation in rough terrain, shorter passengers may find it a bit of work getting in and out. The seats are long-drive comfortable—and about the plushest things within considering that soft-surface areas in the cabin are limited to part of the tops of the doors, armrests, and the console-box lid. Interior storage is king-sized and well distributed throughout. Cushions of the 60/40-split rear seat flip up for extensive storage space on the floor. Operation of the standard premium audio system through the 8-inch touchscreen is uncomplicated. (Satellite radio, navigation, and Apple CarPlay/Android Auto smartphone compatibility are included.) The dual-zone climate-control system benefits from two convenient rotary dials for temperature settings.

Test Drive: 2020 Nissan Titan PRO-4X Crew Cab

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD

The Tundra is offered with only one powertrain: a 381-hp “i-Force” 5.7-liter V8 paired with a 6-speed automatic transmission. TRD Pros come standard with tough-looking BBS-brand 18-inch forged-aluminum wheels.

As of 2020, Tundra’s powerteam checklist had dwindled to a long-serving 381-horsepower 5.7-liter V8 and 6-speed automatic transmission. No surprise for an off-roader, the TRD Pro driveline is electronically controlled 4-wheel drive, though an inconvenient part-time system. With 401 lb-ft of torque and an aggressive rear axle ratio, the Pro is eager off the line, yet cruises easily on the highway. A tromp of the accelerator is rewarded by prompt kickdown from the transmission and a “’scuse me, coming through” warning blast from the exhaust. Tow rating for the TRD Pro CrewMax is 9200 pounds, but the 170-pound-lighter Double Cab can pull an additional 700. While some distance away from big-pickup ride leader Ram, an unladen Pro still does all right for itself with its leaf-spring rear suspension. Driving it as they did toward the end of an especially snowy stretch with deep accumulations, CG editors found its 4-wheel drive undaunted by the conditions. The only worries were at the gas station where they were seeing 14 or fewer mpg from a vehicle that the EPA rates at 13 mpg in the city, 17 on the highway, and 14 combined.

Quick Spin: 2020 GMC Sierra 1500 AT4 Diesel

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD

The Tundra TRD Pro gets a unique grille insert with TOYOTA lettering, LED headlights with LED accent lights, Rigid Industries LED fog lights in the front bumper, and a TRD front skid plate. Blizzard-like conditions in Chicagoland during our late-February session with our test vehicle meant that we had a pickup bed full of snow for a couple days.

Trailer brake and sway controls are included. Safety-enhancing driving aids—forward collision warning and mitigation with pedestrian detection, lane-departure warning, automatic high beams, adaptive cruise control—are part of the standard Toyota Safety Sense P system.

By the way, the Tundra TRD Pro also comes in Super White, Magnetic Gray Metallic, or Midnight Black Metallic—in case you’re not over the Moon for Lunar Rock.

Quick Spin: 2020 Ram 1500 Laramie

Toyota Tundra TRD Pro

The special features of the TRD Pro model add to the appeal of the Toyota Tundra, as does Toyota’s reputation for quality and reliability. However, this truck’s basic design is well over a decade old, and it’s really showing its age compared to domestic-brand rivals that offer better fuel economy and scads of innovative, cutting-edge features. An all-new generation of the Toyota Tundra is in the works, and it’s scheduled to debut as a 2022 model.

Listen to the very entertaining Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

  2021 Toyota Tundra TRD Pro Gallery

(Click below for enlarged images)

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD

5 Cool Things About the Toyota Tundra

2021 Toyota Tundra TRD Pro

For GREAT deals on used vehicles check out Overstock Vehicles TODAY!

Test Drive: 2021 Acura TLX

2021 Acura TLX

2021 Acura TLX SH-AWD Advance in Fathom Blue Pearl

Consumer Guide Test Drive

2021 Acura TLX AWD with Advance Package

ClassPremium Midsize Car

Miles driven: 180

Fuel used: 8.9 gallons

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort B+
Power and Performance B
Fit and Finish A
Fuel Economy B-
Value A-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy B
Tall Guy B
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 272-hp 2.0L
Engine Type Turbo 4-cyl
Transmission 10-speed automatic
Drive Wheels All-wheel drive

Real-world fuel economy: 20.2 mpg

Driving mix: 60% city, 40% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 21/29/24 (city, highway, combined)

Fuel typePremium gas recommended

Base price: $48,300 (not including $1025 destination charge)

Options on test vehicle: None

Price as tested: $49,325

More Acura price and availability information

Quick Hits

The great: Classy, distinctive interior trimmings; nicely balanced ride and handling; generous list of comfort and technology features

The good: Respectable power from turbo 4-cylinder engine; smooth 10-speed transmission

The not so good: Rear-seat space is just OK; not as customizable as most class rivals

John Biel:

The Acura TLX is all new for 2021 and it is, Acura will have you know, its own car. No slicked-up treatment of a concurrent Honda, the premium midsize sedan is built on a body-and-chassis architecture that is exclusive to the brand. It does borrow a powerteam from the RDX premium compact SUV, but that represents a complete change from what powered the previous-generation TLX.

2021 Acura TLX

The sporty, sophisticated dashboard design is a TLX strong point. Sleek wood accents, satin-finish metal trim elements, and classy ambient nighttime lighting help provide a convincingly high-end ambiance.

TLXs come in four states of trim: base, with Technology Package, A-Spec, and with Advance Package. All are available with a choice of front-wheel drive or Acura’s “Super Handling All-Wheel Drive” (SH-AWD), the latter at a $2000 premium. A higher-performance all-wheel-only Type S was slated for a spring ’21 launch. Consumer Guide editors sampled an Advance with SH-AWD, a car that starts at $49,325 with delivery.

Test Drive: 2020 Cadillac CT4-V

2021 Acura TLX

The TLX’s front row is spacious, and the seats are comfortable and supportive. The True Touchpad infotainment interface benefits from an ergonomically placed wrist-rest pad, but using the system requires acclimation and practice–and we’d also recommend getting a quick tutorial from your Acura dealer.

Wider by 2.2 inches and lower by 0.5 inch than its predecessor, the TLX is restyled with a longer dash-to-axle span to conjure up the look of a rear-drive sport sedan in what’s fundamentally a transverse-engine front-drive car. It is fronted by a wider interpretation of Acura’s “Diamond Pentagon” grille and “JewelEye” LED headlights. The hood, front fenders, and front bumper are part of the new model’s extensive complement of aluminum parts.

Quick Spin: 2020 Lexus ES 300h Ultra Luxury

2021 Acura TLX

The front seats are adjusted all the way back in this photo, but even with them set further forward, the TLX’s rear seat is a bit cramped for tall passengers.

Underneath the skin is a body structure that has been made 50 percent more rigid overall and benefits from front and rear underfloor braces. The front suspension changes to double wishbones from MacPherson struts. In the latest version of SH-AWD, torque makes a speedier front-to-rear transfer when necessary, with up to 70 percent of all available twist available to the rear axle. The TLX Advance features standard adaptive damping in which a continuously adjustable valve in each damper raises or lowers fluid pressure based on sensor data, altering fluid flow rates within the tubes and softening or stiffening damping force as road conditions change.

An “Integrated Dynamics System”—Acura’s term for “Comfort, “Normal,” “Sport,” and new configurable “Individual” drive modes—influences things like throttle response, shift points, steering resistance, and damping. There’s subtle difference in driving feel between Comfort and Normal modes, but Sport brings out a clearer change in steering and suspension characteristics—though we wouldn’t go as far as calling the limit of the adaptive damping “race car-stiff” as Acura claims. The car rides quite well, even in Sport, and there’s enough steering feedback for drivers to feel sufficiently in touch with the road below. Handling is good, even in quick corners.

The 2.0-liter turbo 4-cylinder engine generates 272 horsepower at 6500 rpm and 280 lb-ft of torque at 1600-4500 rpm. That’s a little less horsepower than was available from the 3.5-liter V6 in the 2020 TLX Advance, but almost 5 percent more faster-acting torque. The engine is satisfyingly powerful for the vast majority of driving needs with the able assistance of the utterly smooth 10-speed automatic transmission. Sport brings out a clear change in shift points, delaying them to squeeze extra power from each range. The exhaust report can be a little bratty under acceleration, and in those moments undercuts the Acura premium-brand image. TLXs with SH-AWD are rated by the EPA at 21 mpg in the city, 29 mpg on the highway, and 24 combined. When this driver topped off after 64.6 miles, with 48 percent city-style operation, he saw 21.9 mpg.

Naturally, as the king of the pricing hill (at least until the Type S arrives), the Advance has the best of the standard equipment offered in the vehicle line. That includes things like a power moonroof, heated and ventilated front seats, wireless charging, 17-speaker Acura/ELS premium audio, satellite radio, navigation, dual-zone climate control, Wi-Fi hotspot, Apple CarPlay/Android Auto smartphone compatibility, AcuraLink connected services, 7-inch information display in the instrument cluster, collision mitigation and pedestrian detection with emergency braking, adaptive cruise control, lane-departure warning and lane-keeping assist, and blind-spot and rear cross-traffic monitors. Traffic-sign recognition and traffic-jam assist are newly standard for TLXs, too.

Test Drive: 2020 Alfa Romeo Giulia Ti Lusso

2021 Acura TLX

The TLX’s trunk space–13.5 cubic feet–is on par with most class rivals.

Beyond that, the Advance stands out from other models with the adaptive dampers, Pewter Gray Metallic machine finish for its 19-inch alloy wheels, LED puddle lights, power-folding exterior mirrors, rain-sensing windshield wipers, and windshield-wiper deicer. Inside are sport seats with perforated Milano premium leather; 16-way power front seats with power adjustments for lumbar support, thigh extension, and side bolsters; heated steering wheel and rear seats; open-pore wood trim on the console and door panels; head-up warning; surround-view camera system; and a 10.5-Inch head-up instrument display.

An airy, open-feeling cabin provides great driver vision. Attractive and plush front seats are decidedly comfortable. There’s plenty of head- and legroom in front; rear legroom is good but not outstanding, and headroom isn’t as good for tall folks. The big driveline hump rules out a third adult passenger in back. Door tops are thinly padded, but there’s lots of soft-surface material in other places.

I didn’t lose my mind trying to figure out how to input radio presets with the help of the “True Touchpad Interface.” This device is a bit more accurate than something like the late Lexus system—there’s no dragging a fingertip or manipulating a mouse across the active control area while trying to drive—but I still found myself sometimes wondering why a spot on the 10.2-inch display screen was not activating in response to where I thought I was touching the console pad. A padded handrest does a good job of keeping errant mitts from contacting the touchpad and unintentionally changing stations or screen views.

Meet the 2021 Consumer Guide Best Buys

2021 Acura TLX

The TLX’s turbocharged 2.0-liter 4-cylinder puts out a healthy 272 horsepower. A high-performance Type S model is set to join the TLX lineup in spring 2021; it will be powered by a 355-hp turbocharged 3.0-liter V6. TLXs with all-wheel drive and the Advance Package come standard with 19-inch alloy wheels on Michelin Primacy all-season tires.

Cabin storage options are varied and usefully sized. Trunk capacity of 13.5 cubic feet is a slight decrease from before. The flat floor narrows quite a bit between the wheel houses. Rear 60/40 seats fold flat, with a smooth transition from trunk floor to retracted seats, but a bulkhead at the threshold constricts the opening somewhat. There’s some hidden storage in a foam organizer under the floor.

The TLX has a record of being Acura’s best-selling sedan. By being its own car for 2021, it should remain a car lots of people will want to own.

Indulgence Madness! A Gallery of Eighties Personal Luxury Car Ads

2021 Acura TLX

The redesigned-for-2021 TLX wears familiar Acura styling themes, but applies them to striking new long-hood/short-deck body proportions. In addition to its distinctive design, the new TLX offers athletic driving manners, a very nicely finished cabin, and a generous list of tech-forward features–it continues as a Consumer Guide Best Buy this year.

(Click below for enlarged images)

Follow John on Twitter

Listen to the very entertaining Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

2021 Acura TLX Gallery

2021 Acura TLX

Test Drive: 2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge in Jubilee Silver

2020 G902020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge

Class: Premium Large Car

Miles driven: 213

Fuel used: 14.5 gallons

Real-world fuel economy: 14.7 mpg

Driving mix: 45% city, 55% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 12/18/14 (city, highway, combined)

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort A
Power and Performance A-
Fit and Finish A
Fuel Economy D
Value C-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy A+
Tall Guy A
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 593-hp 6.6L
Engine Type V12
Transmission 8-speed automatic
Drive Wheels Rear-wheel drive

Fuel type: Premium gas required

Base price: $356,500 (not including $2750 destination charge)

Options on test vehicle: Black Badge Package ($50,000), Bespoke Interior ($5600), Rolls-Royce Signature Package ($11,275) Mandarin-color top ($5425), Mandarin-color pinstripe applied to wheel centre ($2400), single Mandarin-color coachline pinstripe ($1775), Aero Cowling rear-seat tonneau cover ($25,750), RR embossing to interior door panels ($1975), Selby Grey seat-piping accents ($3175), Driver Assistance 3 Package ($8325), Gas Guzzler tax ($2600)

Price as tested: $477,550

Quick Hits

The great: Top-of-the-heap luxury; built-to-order customizability; serene ride quality

The good: Generous front-seat space; smooth, abundant power from V12 engine

The not so good: Prices fit for royalty; voracious thirst for premium fuel; cramped trunk space for a vehicle this large

Check out our Premium Large Car Best Buys

John Biel

There are, we imagine, strange elements to just about any occupation, tasks that people need to perform that seemingly defy reason, and only on reflection do they get to ask, “Did I really just do that? For money?”

For a Consumer Guide Automotive editor, this “what just happened here?” sense hits whenever something like a 2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn convertible shows up outside the building. Admittedly, there are few cars like it, and that’s the point. We’ll get 100 or more review vehicles a year through Consumer Guide Supreme World Headquarters, so we’re certainly comfortable discussing the features and performance of cars and trucks that Americans purchase by the tens of thousands. Throw a Roller in the mix, however, and it makes you question what you’re doing.

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn

Our Dawn test vehicle was equipped with the $50,000 Black Badge package (which includes blacked-out body trim) and the $25,750 Aero Cowling rear-seat tonneau cover, which includes built-in lockable storage compartments.

Whenever this happens—and it does now and then—we’re out of our comfort zone. Off the bat, the sums involved are staggering relative to the many vehicles we review—even some of the true luxury products. With jaws hanging open, we can’t help staring and pointing at . . . that price: $361,850 (with delivery and $2600 Gas Guzzler Tax), and that’s just for starters. We can’t resist remarking that a single option, a removable “aero” tonneau cover over the rear seats that creates a two-seater look, costs more than an entire Volkswagen Golf TSI, or that the fee for the Black Badge décor-and-performance package that gives the test car its identity would cover a fantastic wedding present for your favorite young couple—two Golf TSIs. We look at the fuel-economy portion of the window sticker and are amazed to the point of amusement at the note that says a Dawn owner is projected to spend $10,000 more in fuel over five years than the owner of “the average new vehicle,” this after having parted with $477,550 to get the car in the first place.

More Rolls-Royce news and reviews

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge

Modern-day Rolls-Royce interiors do a nice job of balancing technology and tradition by offering current convenience features with classic-style switchgear and detailing. “Technical Fibre” carbon-fiber trim inserts take the place of the expected exotic-wood trim, and that Mandarin color is used liberally–even on the convertible top (see gallery below).

All of our unseemly talk of money certainly marks us as being from the “if you have to ask, you can’t afford it” side of the tracks. Wouldn’t someone more—shall we say—familiar with this type of car be better suited to critique it? Perhaps. The thing is, people who fit that description sure as heck don’t work as Internet auto writers (if they have to work at all). It falls to us then.

Even figuring out what to say about the Rolls-Royce Dawn seems to defy sense and meaning. If we roll up our sleeves and dive in to the normal type of CG review, we’ll inevitably mention the smooth but strong 6.6-liter V12 engine, the serene ride quality, and the exceptional materials and fit and finish. But saying so almost seems unnecessary, because 478 grand. We often make judgements on performance and value between the vehicles we review for the benefit of readers who may be weighing a buying decision, but what’s the competitive set for the Rolls, a brand that Automotive News reports sold 1320 cars in the U.S. in 2019? Plus, the world being what it is, we can’t imagine that even the most awed review we could give the Dawn is going to turn the head of the shopper looking for “the one” among the 19 compact SUVs on the market.

Test Drive: 2020 BMW M8 Competition Convertible

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge

All Dawns have rear-hinged doors that power open or closed–which is good, because the open doors’ handles are a bit hard to grab when seated. Eye-grabbing Mandarin orange leather upholstery is available as part of the $5600 Bespoke Interior package. Both doorjambs have a built-in umbrella that pops out at the press of a button.

All things considered, then, about all we can do is enjoy the ride in something from outside the routine. The 2020 Black Badge is even further “outside” than the last Dawn we briefly drove in 2017.

The Black Badge package renders the car’s body moldings and classic grille in gloss black, with the hideaway “Spirit of Ecstasy” hood ornament in a dark-chrome finish. Wheels are a carbon/alloy composite, 21 inches in diameter. The interior sports light-gray contrast stitching and “RR” monograms in the headrests of the sumptuous natural-grain leather seats (ventilated in front), with technical-fiber trim in place of wood on the dashboard, doors, and console. Meanwhile, a sport exhaust and engine output raised by 30 horsepower make this a slightly less-sedate Rolls-Royce.

Test Drive: 2020 Mercedes-AMG GT C Roadster

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge

The Dawn’s powerplant is suitably regal and powerful–a BMW-built 6.6-liter V12 that puts out 593 horsepower in Black Badge form. The “RR” badges in the center of the 21-inch carbon/alloy composite wheels are always upright; they’re fixed to the hubs, so they don’t turn with the rest of the wheel. The hand-painted Mandarin orange pinstripe applied to the wheel centers is a $2400 option, and the matching coachline (beltline) pinstripes are another $1775.

Pumped up to 593 horsepower—but with the same 605 lb-ft of torque as in the standard-tune engine—the twin-turbocharged BMW V12 makes the big convertible a little speedier but no noisier, and no less smooth. The utterly unobtrusive 8-speed automatic transmission helps there. The Black Badge engine loses one mpg in EPA highway-mileage ratings, slipping to an estimated 18, but city and combined projections stay the same at 12 and 14 mpg, respectively. CG’s 213-mile test with approximately 45 percent city-style operation worked out to 14.7 mpg.

As expected for a car of this size and purpose, ride is better than handling. It veritably swallows surface irregularities such as railroad tracks with electronic variable damping and rear self-leveling air springs. However, steering is on the slow side, so cornering response is somewhat laggard.

Test Drive: 2021 Lexus LC 500 Convertible

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge

A power-retractable Spirit of Ecstasy hood ornament is standard, and it too gets the Black Badge dark-finish treatment.

None of that will bother a driver and up to three additional passengers on an open-road cruise, however. All occupants enjoy ample legroom, and good headroom under the raised top. With the top down, front passengers experience little wind buffeting. Our Black Badge test car was considerably more vibrant than our ’17 Dawn, with orange Mandarin upholstery, body striping, and even convertible top (over a Jubilee Silver body). The cabin glistens with many chrome highlights. Switchgear is tight yet effortless to operate. BMW’s iDrive with central control from the console serves as the infotainment system—with the attendant complication. Four-zone climate control is managed by rotating dials for fan speed, waferlike dials for temperature settings, and tiny buttons for things like seat heaters and defrosters.

With the kind of power and luxury built into a Rolls-Royce Dawn, there’s certainly nothing hard about driving one. That’s cushy duty. It’s just a little tough to comprehend, though.

Forgotten Concept: Chrysler Imperial

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn

If the 2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn were a gourmet meal, it would be a decadent feast where highly skilled chefs used all the sugar, butter, salt, and red meat they wanted. It’s pure automotive luxury and indulgence–with a price tag to match.

Click below for enlarged images

Follow John on Twitter

Listen to the very entertaining Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

2020 Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge Gallery

Rolls-Royce Dawn Black Badge


For GREAT deals on a new or used Chevrolet check out Community Chevrolet TODAY!

First Spin: 2021 Cadillac Escalade

2021 Cadillac Escalade

2021 Cadillac Escalade Platinum in Crystal White Tricoat

Consumer Guide Automotive Cadillac’s trademark “Standard of the World” tagline was first employed by the luxury brand after winning the 1908 Dewar Trophy, an honor presented by Britain’s Royal Automobile Club to recognize carmakers for “furthering the interests and advancements of the industry.”

More Consumer Guide First Spins

Though use of the Standard of the World slogan has lapsed from time to time over the past century, Cadillac’s marketing team has kept the familiar words handy, applying them mostly to print advertising at irregular intervals.

2021 Cadillac Escalade Platinum

Measuring in at 211.9 inches, the standard-length 2021 Escalade is 8 inches longer overall than the previous-gen model.

Sadly, it has been several decades since anyone would claim with any degree of sincerity that Cadillac was, indeed, the Standard of the World. One reason for this is that Cadillac is now positioned as a mainstream premium brand, generally priced and cross-shopped against products from Lincoln and lower-priced offerings from the likes of BMW and Mercedes-Benz. This puts Cadillac in a difficult place from which to make claims of absolute global superiority. Additionally, a generation of lackluster product offerings, including most models designed and sold in the Eighties and Nineties, did considerable damage to Cadillac’s reputation.

At least initially, the first Escalades seemed poised to be another blight on Cadillac’s good name. Though a sales success from its inception in 1998, the big, brash, overtly trucky Escalade was initially regarded by the automotive media—and much of the buying public—as a cheap, easy, and cynical way for Cadillac to cash in on America’s budding hunger for SUVs.

Test Drive: 2017 Cadillac Escalade

2021 Cadillac Escalade platinum

Given the plethora of available features, the Escalade’s control layout is laudably simple. Drivers unwilling to use the infotainment touchscreen may avail themselves of the rotary controller located aft of the shift lever on the center console, which can be used for most infotainment functions instead.

Literally a re-trimmed Chevrolet Tahoe with an upscale price tag, the chrome-laden Escalade became a rolling tribute to indulgent living and was quickly embraced by both hip-hop culture and spend-happy suburbanites. Any concern regarding the impact of selling a giant, fuel-thirsty, arguably garish SUV to Cadillac’s reputation as a purveyor of refined luxury vehicles became moot as the Escalade quickly became the single most profitable vehicle in the entire General Motors lineup.

Test Drive: Lincoln Navigator Reserve

Curved OLED

The Escalade’s massive OLED dash display screen is notable for its image clarity (twice the pixel density of a 4K TV, according to Cadillac) and for being the first curved LED display used in an automobile.

Funny thing about the Escalade, though: With each new generation, the big Cadillac became less and less a showroom sore thumb, and more the core element by which the brand was defined. Though the Escalade is still closely related to the Chevrolet Tahoe—and Chevy Suburban, as well as the similar GMC Yukon and Yukon XL—Cadillac designers have taken care to see that the Escalade stands alone among GM’s big trucks, by giving it unique interiors, more powerful standard engines, and the sort of premium features that customers would expect to find on true luxury vehicles. And now that crossovers and SUVs account for roughly two thirds of all light-duty vehicle sales, the Escalade seems exactly like the kind of thing you might find at an American luxury-vehicle dealership.

First Look: Jeep Grand Wagoneer Concept

Escalade 2nd-row seating

There’s big-adult-friendly space in the second-row seats, which also flip forward for access to the third row.

And, as this is published, Cadillac dealers are welcoming the first wave of fifth-generation Escalades into their showrooms, likely encouraged by the seemingly countless advancements and new features the big profit generator boasts. More importantly, perhaps, the 2021 Escalade represents Cadillac’s best effort in at least a generation to produce a vehicle that is arguably best in class.

The Escalade, like its downmarket Chevrolet and GMC cousins, is a larger vehicle for 2021. The standard-length Escalade rides on a 120.9-inch wheelbase and measures 211.9 inches long overall—respectively, that’s 4.9 inches and 8 inches longer than the previous-gen model. The long-wheelbase Escalade ESV now rides on a 134.1-inch wheelbase (up 4.1 inches) and stretches 227 inches overall (up 2.7 inches). Both variants are now 2.4 inches taller as well.

First Spin: 2021 GMC Yukon

2021 Cadillac Escalade Platinum

The Escalade’s wheelbase stretch for 2021 greatly improves passenger space in the third-row seats–legroom grows by 10 inches.

The added length pays off in terms of passenger room and comfort. Except for front-row head- and legroom, both of which decline by less than an inch for 2021, passenger room is more generous. Standard-length Escalades now boast up to 42 inches of second-row legroom (a 3-inch improvement) and 35 inches of third-row legroom (up 10 inches.) The ESV shares the standard-length Escalade’s second-row dimensions, but boasts 37 inches of third-row legroom, up 2 over the ’20 ESV.

Predictably, cargo volume has expanded for 2021 as well. The big news (pun intended) is the added cargo volume aft of the third-row seatbacks. Standard-length models now accommodate up to 25.5 cubic feet of stuff (up from 15.2), and ESVs up to 42.9 feet (up from 39.3).

Also new for 2021 is Escalade’s rear suspension. Replacing the previous generation’s solid-axle/coil-spring arrangement is a sophisticated independent multilink system which, in part, allowed Cadillac to lower the cargo-area load floor, creating some of that additional cargo space discussed above.

Returning for 2021 is GM’s Magnetic Ride Control (MRC) adaptive suspension system. Found also on other GM vehicles (including the Chevrolet Corvette), MRC uses sensors to “read” the road and make real-time shock-absorber adjustments accordingly. The MRC is supplemented on higher trim levels by Cadillac’s new Air Ride Adaptive Suspension, which, among other functions, lowers the vehicle for easy entry and exit, and raises the vehicle for added off-road clearance when needed.

Also returning for 2021 is Escalade’s burly 6.2-liter V8, which is again rated at 420 horsepower and 460 lb-ft of torque. Newly optional is a 3.0-liter turbodiesel six, which is rated at 277 horsepower and matches the V8 exactly for torque. Both engines mate to a 10-speed automatic transmission and a limited-slip rear axle, and offer available all-wheel drive. The EPA rates Escalades equipped with the V8 engine at 15 mpg in the city, 20 on the highway, and 17 combined. Those numbers each drop by one on AWD models. Diesel-engine estimates are not yet available.

Test Drive: 2020 Infiniti QX80 Limited

Cadillac AKG Audio

The new Escalade marks the first time AKG–a maker of high-end microphones, headphones and audio systems–has ventured into automotive audio. A 12-speaker system is standard, and a 36-speaker system is available.

If you’ve heard any of the buzz preceding the launch of Caddy’s new big rigs, you’ve liked heard about the “OLED” curved instrument panel. The OLED (Organic Light Emitting Diode) screens cover a whopping 38 inches of dashboard space, and include a trip-computer panel to the left of the instrument panel, the instrument panel itself, and the console infotainment screen in what looks convincingly like a single flowing panel. The “organic” part of OLED is the curve of the panels, which wrap gently around the driver, providing better sightlines and arguably easier touch operation. Per Cadillac, the Escalade is the first vehicle to employ a curved LED panel.

All of this tech is used to good effect. Cadillac boasts that the resolution of the OLED display is sharper than that of a 4K TV, a claim which seems reasonable to us; the screens also seem nearly impervious to washing out in bright sunlight.

The infotainment-touchscreen look and operation will feel familiar to anyone who has experienced either earlier versions of Cadillac’s CUE operating system or Apple CarPlay. For drivers unwilling to smudge the touchscreen, a BMW iDrive-like rotary knob can be employed for most functions instead.

Quick Spin: 2020 Ford Expedition MAX Platinum

2021 Cadillac Escalade

As expected, the Escalade offers excellent cargo space, and it’s especially improved in the regular-length models for 2021. There’s 25.5 cubic feet behind the third row, 72.9 behind the second row, and 121.0 behind the first row.

It’s the huge instrument panel (IP) which impresses most. The IP can be used in any of four modes, two of which present various combinations of information. Another appears as a conventional gauge cluster, including a large, round speedometer. The fourth mode allows the driver to view the same navigation-screen map as displayed on the main infotainment screen, but at a different scale—which proved surprisingly handy when this editor chose to sneak through a subdivision in search of a shortcut around traffic during one especially challenging commute.

Quick Spin: 2020 Nissan Armada Platinum

2021 Cadillac Escalade Platinum

The right-side cargo-area wall is home to a handy electrical outlet, seat-back-fold release-latch buttons for the second-row seats, and power folding/raising buttons for the third-row seats.

Also available is Augmented Reality Navigation, which displays a forward-facing camera view on the IP screen and overlays the real-time video image with graphic—and very easy to follow—navigation arrows and prompts. This can be especially helpful when trying to determine what lane on the highway to stay in, or which off-ramp to take. The Augmented Reality system can also be handy when driving directly into the sun, as the filtered image is free of haze and glare.

Other controls are largely convenient and easy to manipulate. Kudos to Cadillac for keeping the console area clean and uncluttered.

Speaking of the interior, Consumer Guide’s access to the new Escalade thus far has been limited to a standard-length Platinum model with 4WD. The top-line trim level’s cabin presents well, with plenty of high-grade leather, luxurious-looking real-wood trim, and tastefully applied bright accents. We did notice a few spots—the lower seat sides when viewed from outside the truck—where some materials cost-cutting seems to have taken place, but from a seated position in the vehicle, the cabin looks, well, world class.

On the road the V8 engine shines, providing plenty of power and working well with the polished 10-speed automatic transmission. The once-prominent exhaust note seems to have been squelched a bit for 2021—though a welcome burble can he heard when taking off from a stop, or when passing or merging. Otherwise, the Escalade cabin is impressively quiet; in fact, it is among the quietest vehicles we’ve reviewed in some time.

Test Drive: 2019 BMW X7

2021 Cadillac Escalade Platinum

It took us a minute to find the Escalade’s power-rear-liftgate button–it’s “hidden” in the Cadillac crest badge.

Ride quality, too, is impressive. The Escalade offers four drive modes: Tour, Sport, Off-Road, and Tow/Haul. Tour is the default standard mode, and in this setting the Escalade’s ride quality is sublime. Selecting the Sport mode firms things up a bit, with little detriment to ride quality. In Sport mode, the Escalade is surprisingly easy to hustle through traffic, and the reduced lean in corners is welcome. We would be loath to suggest this big Caddy is actually sporty, but it gets around well given its mass. We suggest keeping the Escalade in Sport mode until you hit the highway, and falling back to Tour mode for optimal ride comfort. Note that our experience is limited at this point to an Escalade equipped with the Air Ride Adaptive Suspension. We hope to report on a less-well-equipped example sometime soon.

The Escalade list of safety and driver assistance features is almost too long to list, but in addition to the expected features are front pedestrian detection and braking, rear pedestrian alert, automatic emergency braking, rear camera mirror, rear cross-traffic alert, lane-change alert with blind-spot alert, and lane-keep assist with lane-departure warning. Also, a high-definition surround-view camera can be activated at any time to assist with low-speed, tight-spot maneuvering.

Cadillac’s enhanced Super Cruise semi-autonomous driving system will also be available on the 2021 Escalade, but was not included on our test truck. You can read about our experience with an earlier version of this system here.

Cadillac claims it has largely held the line on Escalade pricing, but that doesn’t prevent us from wincing a little when reading the window sticker. The Escalade is offered in five trim levels for 2021: Luxury ($76,195), Premium Luxury ($82,995), Sport ($85,595), Premium Luxury Platinum ($99,995), and Sport Platinum (also $99,995). All of these starting prices are sans options and the $1295 destination charge.

Test Drive: 2018 Cadillac CT6 with Super Cruise

Escalade Wheels

The Escalade’s standard 6.2-liter V8–which is essentially carried over from the previous-gen model–is rated at a healthy 420 horsepower. Twenty-two-inch 10-spoke polished wheels are standard on the Premium Luxury Platinum.

For each trim level, moving to the long-wheelbase ESV adds exactly $3000 to the bottom line; adding all-wheel drive also tacks on a $3000 premium. The Sport models are new for 2021; they don’t include any performance upgrades, but do add specific trim elements such as a unique mesh grille texture, black grille surround, and black bodyside moldings.

Consumer Guide’s well-equipped 4WD Platinum came to $110,565. For the record, we averaged a reasonable 17.7 mpg in a test that consisted of a slight majority of highway driving. So, we were right on par with the Escalade’s EPA-estimated economy.

A quick note about the new AKG audio system: We’re not audiophiles, but to this editor’s ears, this is one of the best car-audio systems currently available. Note that we’ve only been exposed to the top-line 36-speaker Studio Reference system, and not the standard 19-speaker arrangement found in lower trim levels.

So, is Escalade the large-luxury-SUV Standard of the World? Having spent little time with SUVs such as the Bentley Bentayga and Rolls-Royce Cullinan, we’re not entirely comfortable passing that judgement. That said, the 2021 Escalade is certainly the vehicle in Cadillac’s lineup most worthy of a “best-in-class” nomination.

The new Escalade is certainly everything returning shoppers could want in a huge Cadillac SUV. For 2021, the truck is now brimming with high-tech features and a heightened level of refinement that may well lure European big-truck intenders out of their rides. Color us impressed.

Quick Spin: 2020 Cadillac XT6 Sport

2021 Cadillac Escalade platinum

The redesigned-for-2021 Escalade brings a whole new level of technology, luxury features, and all-around refinement to Cadillac’s biggest, bling-iest SUV.

Click below for enlarged images

Follow Tom on Twitter

Listen to the very entertaining Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

2021 Cadillac Escalade Platinum Gallery

2021 Cadillac Escalade

Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast, Episode 50: LEGO Cars, 2021 Nissan Rogue

Lego Cars

Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

Whether you drive a car, need a car, or just occasionally bum a ride with friends, you’ve come to the right place. Join the editors of Consumer Guide Automotive as they break down everything that’s going on in the auto world. New-car reviews, shopping tips, driving green, electric cars, classic cars, and plenty of great guests. This is the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast.

Episode: 50

Broadcast date: October 11, 2020

Guest: Cherise Threewitt

LEGO Cars, 2021 Nissan Rogue

Host Tom Appel and co-hosts Jill Ciminillo and Damon Bell start the show by talking about Jaguar’s recent decision to discontinue its XE compact sedan and the station-wagon version of its XF midsize car, before moving on to Damon’s press-preview test drive of the redesigned-for-2021 Nissan Rogue. Freelance auto writer Cherise Threewitt joins us for a fun chat about her informative article on LEGO’s various automotive building sets, and the design processes that bring them to market. Tom has a tricky quiz on wheelbases (yes, wheelbases) for Damon and Jill, and Damon runs down the latest articles on the Consumer Guide Daily Drive blog–including a test-drive review of the 2020 Mercedes-AMG GT C Roadster.

The Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast is broadcast every Sunday on Chicago’s WCPT AM 820 at 1:00 PM CST.

Discussed this week:

First Spin: 2021 Nissan Rogue

Cherise Threewitt’s Homepage

An insider’s guide to LEGO cars, from bite-sized to life-sized

Test Drive: 2020 Mercedes-AMG GT C Roadster

Forgotten Concept: Toyota CX-80

Follow the crew:

The CG Daily Drive Blog

Car Stuff Facebook Page

Consumer Guide on Twitter

Tom on Twitter

Damon on Twitter

Jill on Twitter

Cherise Threewitt on Twitter

Drive, She Said (Jill’s blog)

Tom on the radio:

Tom on the Nick Digilio Show

Tom on Green Sense Radio

Tom on the Stan Milam Show

The Crew

LEGO Cars

For GREAT deals on a new or used Toyota check out Right Toyota TODAY!

Test Drive: 2020 Volkswagen Golf TSI

Volkswagen Golf TSI

2020 Volkswagen Golf TSI in Tungsten Silver Metallic

VW Golf2020 Volkswagen Golf TSI

Class: Compact Car

Miles driven: 468

Fuel used: 13.2 gallons

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort B
Power and Performance B-
Fit and Finish B+
Fuel Economy A
Value A-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy B
Tall Guy B
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 147-hp 1.4L
Engine Type Turbo 4-cylinder
Transmission 6-speed manual
Drive Wheels Front-wheel drive

Real-world fuel economy: 35.3 mpg

Driving mix: 35% city, 65% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 28/36/31 (city, highway, combined)

Fuel type: Regular gas

Base price: $23,195 (not including $920 destination charge)

Options on test vehicle: none

Price as tested: $24,115

Quick Hits

The great: Ride and handling balance; logical control layout; quick, responsive steering; excellent manual transmission and shifter

The good: Interior materials and assembly quality; passenger and cargo space

The not so good: Rear corner visibility; only one trim level available for 2020

More Golf price and availability information

John Biel

The Volkswagen Golf gives off the impression that it’s about to skip town in a hurry. For 2020, it has gotten rid of a few things it can’t carry—wagons, electrics, and the high-performance R model—and it has stuffed all it can hold into one bundle, a new TSI. Listen . . . is that the back window to the fire escape being raised?

The lovable little hatchback that first appeared in America 45 years ago as the Rabbit sure seems destined to jump a midnight freight to parts unknown. While VW has introduced an all-new eighth-generation Golf, the company hasn’t yet confirmed that it will offer that car in the U.S., save for the sporting, popular GTI (which also continues for ’20) and perhaps a revived Golf R.

Volkswagen Golf TSI

The Golf’s clean, European styling gives it an upscale feel and helps is stand out in the mainstream compact-car class. Standard features include automatic headlamps with LED running lights, LED taillights, and heated power mirrors.

In 2019 the “basic” Golf came in S and SE trim levels. The TSI that Consumer Guide editors tested is something of a cross between them. Though priced less than a ’19 SE, the TSI—which starts at $24,115 with delivery—salvages some of its standard features, including 16-inch alloy wheels, heated washer nozzles for the rain-sensing windshield wipers, panoramic sunroof, leatherette upholstery, heated front seats, and “KESSY” keyless entry and starting. Plus, the ’20 Golf comes with an updated VW Car-Net telematics system and the addition of Wi-Fi capability.

2020 Golf

The Golf boasts a sporty, straightforward dashboard layout with simple, easy-to-use controls. A slick-shifting 6-speed manual transmission is standard; an 8-speed automatic is an $800 option.

Other standard equipment is like what was found on the 2019 Golf S. Unfortunately, that includes the lesser of the audio systems, the 6-speaker Composition with a 6.5-inch color touchscreen, AM/FM radio, and a USB port. The remainder consists of automatic halogen headlights, LED taillights, heated power-adjusted side mirrors with integral turn signals, an adjustable cargo floor, manual climate system, leather-wrapped sport steering wheel and gearshift knob, tilt/telescoping steering column, 6-way partial power-adjustable front seats, adjustable console armrest, twin illuminated visor vanity mirrors, multifunction trip computer, Bluetooth audio streaming for compatible devices, three 12-volt power outlets, forward-collision warning, autonomous emergency braking, blind-spot alert, and rear cross-traffic alert.

First Look: 2021 Mazda 3

2020 Golf

Though the Golf is essentially a mono-spec car for 2020, that single trim level comes well-equipped, with a nicely finished cabin. Standard features include leatherette upholstery, heated front seats, and a panoramic sunroof. Rear seat space is decent for the class–average-size adults can fit, though legroom can be tight behind a tall front-seater.

Power comes from the 147-horsepower turbocharged 1.4-liter 4-cylinder engine that was new to the Golf in 2019. With its peak 184 lb-ft of torque on duty at just 1400 rpm, the engine shakes off a momentary breath of turbo lag for lively street driving. It’s a fairly quiet mill, even in sustained highway cruising, but a little short on passing power. The test car was equipped with the 6-speed manual transmission that is standard but can be replaced by an extra-cost 8-speed automatic. The only problem with the happily cooperative manual was a squeaky clutch pedal that whistled a little “wee-ooo” whenever it moved in either direction. EPA fuel-economy estimates for this powerteam are 28 mpg in city driving, 36 mpg on the highway, and 31 combined, but this driver recorded 43.6 mpg upon filling up after a 74-mile stint with 55 percent city-type operation.

Weighing in at just 2939 pounds (with the manual trans), the TSI’s handling remains as nicely nimble as any recent Golf, especially around town. Steering is easy and quickly responsive, and cornering lean is well managed. The ride from the fully independent suspension is compliant without totally sacrificing the firm ride familiar in European cars, and braking is good.

Quick Spin: 2020 Mazda 3 Hatchback

2020 Golf

The Golf’s hatchback body layout provides fine cargo versatility–there’s 17.4 cubic feet of cargo space behind the back seats, and 53.7 cu. ft. when the rear seatbacks are folded down.

Throughout its history, the Rabbit/Golf has delivered impressive roominess for a small car. The seventh-generation job, which dates to 2015, is no different. In back, there is a 17.4-cubic-foot load space on a wide, flat floor that can be adjusted to accommodate taller items. Even at its “normal” level, there’s clearance for broad, flat items to rest atop the spare tire below. Open bins at the rear corners of the cargo hold are handy for containing small incidentals, and one of the electrical inputs is installed in back. Lots more space becomes available when the 60/40-split rear seats are retracted (they fold almost flat); with the front passenger seat pushed forward, this tester was able to fit a window screen that was a little more than 5 feet long in the car. A central pass-through in the middle of the rear seat provides more flexibility.

Front passengers have good head- and legroom, and settle into comfortable and supportive seats. Two adults seated in the rear row will find close but not cramped legroom, plus plentiful headroom. Driver vision is fairly open, save to the rear corners, where the wide roof pillars form a considerable block.

Test Drive: 2020 Nissan Sentra SR Premium

2020 Golf

The turbocharged 1.4-liter 4-cylinder puts out 147 horsepower, and provides sufficient acceleration for everyday driving. (Those with a need for more speed should check out the performance-oriented Golf GTI, a perennial Consumer Guide Best Buy in our sporty/performance car class.) Sixteen-inch alloy wheels are standard equipment.

The dashboard and front doors present considerable soft, pliable surfaces, though rear door panels are topped by grained plastic. Storage pockets in all four doors have a flocked lining, an uncommon touch at this price level. Other cabin storage facilities are a big glove box, a tiny console cubby, a small covered bin with the USB port at the front of the console, a pull-out tray to the left of the steering column, and a pouch on the back of each front seat. Exposed cup holders reside in the console and the pull-down armrest in the center of the rear seat. Yes, the Golf infotainment system is much more basic than those of many rivals, but it is very easy to use and it has Apple CarPlay/Android Auto smartphone compatibility. The climate system is similarly direct: Three convenient dials set temperature, fan speed, and mode, and a small cluster of buttons handle anything else.

Affordable, functional, and generally fun to drive, a car like the Golf would be sad to lose if it takes a powder. Maybe we should keep a light in the window.

Test Drive: 2019 Kia Forte EX

Volkswagen Golf TSI

The current-generation Golf is pretty much at the end of its road. An all-new eight-generation Golf has launched in Europe, but sadly, it appears unlikely that the main-line, non-performance models will come to the U.S.

Check out the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

2020 Volkswagen Golf Gallery

2020 Volkswagen Golf

Test Drive: 2020 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X Crew Cab

2020 Nissan Frontier

2020 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X Crew Cab in Gun Metallic

2015 Audi Q52020 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X Crew Cab

Class: Compact Pickup

Miles driven: 170

Fuel used: 10.8 gallons

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort C+
Power and Performance B
Fit and Finish C+
Fuel Economy B-
Value B-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy B
Tall Guy B
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 310-hp 3.8-liter
Engine Type V6
Transmission 9-speed automatic
Drive Wheels 4WD

Real-world fuel economy: 15.7 mpg

Driving mix: 60% city, 40% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 15/21/17 (city/highway/combined)

Fuel type: Regular gas

Base price: $37,490 (not including $1095 destination charge)

Options on test vehicle: none

Price as tested: $38,585

Quick Hits

The great: Peppy new V6 engine; competitive pricing with a decent amount of standard equipment

The good: Simple, straightforward control layout; off-road capabilities of PRO-4X model

The not so good: Basic design is 15 years old; smaller rear-seat area than some class competitors; jittery ride; lots of hard plastic in the interior

More Frontier price and availability information

John Biel

We won’t say it’s old, but the Nissan Frontier compact pickup currently on the market could serve as its own retro special edition. The 2020 truck is fundamentally the 2005 model as visually refreshed for 2009. Yeah, 2009.

Of course, in all that time the Frontier was improved as much as was practical for what had been the bargain buy in a vehicle class that nearly evaporated before staging a strong comeback in the last couple of years. Even now, on the eve of a next-generation Frontier (which is slated to arrive as a 2021 model), it gets a completely new powerteam and some added standard equipment.

2020 Nissan Frontier

As the off-road-focused model of the Frontier lineup, the PRO-4X comes standard with Bilstein off-road shocks, a rear-differential locker, and skid plates to protect underbody components. The beefy roof rack is also standard.

Consumer Guide tried out the new 3.8-liter V6/9-speed automatic Frontier in an off-road-oriented PRO-4X Crew Cab. With the SL trim cut from the line—S and SV models remain—the PRO-4X sits atop the price hierarchy in 2020, starting at $38,595 with delivery. That‘s an increase of about $4500 from ’19, mostly attributable to the change in engine and transmission and the addition of a leather-covered shifter knob and push-button starting as standard equipment. (The base S, which gets all those features plus a manual tilt steering wheel, power windows, and power door locks with driver-side auto-down, jumps approximately $7800 to $27,885 for the price-leader rear-wheel-drive King Cab.)

Test Drive: 2020 Nissan Titan PRO-4X Crew Cab

2020 Nissan Frontier

The Frontier’s aged basic design is especially apparent in its dashboard layout. Some pickup buyers might appreciate the straightforward, old-school design, but others will likely be turned off by the copious amount of hard plastic and the small infotainment screen.

The 3.8 V6 with automatic is the only way to go in 2020. The engine replaces both a 152-horsepower 2.5-liter 4-cylinder and a 261-horse 4.0-liter V6. The trans steps in for the formerly used 5- and 6-speed manuals and a 5-speed automatic. Despite its smaller displacement, the 310-horsepower 3.8 makes nearly 20 percent more power than the old V6 thanks to direct injection and new cylinder heads with integrated exhaust manifold. (However, maximum torque is unchanged at 281 lb-ft.) The new powerteam makes this a pretty quick and responsive truck that’s really eager off the line, and acceptably quiet.

The additional go should go further, too. EPA fuel-economy estimates are slightly increased for the ’20 Frontier. Models with the part-time 4-wheel drive that’s standard on the PRO-4X are tagged for 17 mpg in the city, 23 mpg on the highway, and 19 mpg combined. Still, this driver averaged just 16.5 mpg after covering 59 miles, 45 percent of which was in city-type use.

Compact Madness! A Gallery of Small-Truck Ads

2020 Nissan Frontier

Legroom is a bit tight in the back seats, and the seat backs sit at an upright angle. Headroom is quite good, however. There are no HVAC vents for rear-seat passengers, but dual cup holders flip down from the center console.

The name may read like an athlete’s-foot remedy, but the PRO-4X is the Frontier representative to the “off-road-special” caucus within the pickup market. It comes with specific 16-inch machine-finish alloy wheels; white-letter all-terrain tires; a locking rear differential; Bilstein high-pressure off-road shock absorbers; and skid plates to shield the undersides of the oil pan, fuel tank, and transfer case. Visual distinctions come down to white-faced gauges ringed in satin-chrome accents and “tire-tread” graphics on the sides of the 5-foot cargo bed. Ride isn’t too bad for this type of truck. In commuting, it came across as a little jittery at highway speeds, but not badly damped, and road cracks and joints didn’t upset it too much. Steering is pretty easy, too. Even for its age, this is not a truck you have to manhandle to get it to do anything.

Quick Spin: 2020 Ford Ranger Lariat SuperCrew

Nissan 3.8-liter V6

The Frontier itself may be old, but it gets an all-new powertrain for 2020: a 310-hp 3.8-liter V6 that’s paired with a 9-speed automatic transmission. Sixteen-inch alloy wheels on all-terrain tires are standard on the PRO-4X.

Passenger space up front room is pretty good and the seats are comfy. The rear seat has less legroom than you might expect from a crew cab (yes, it’s a compact, but still . . .), and the seat back is kind of upright and not lushly padded. Three friendly adults might be able to occupy the rear seat—an almost flat floor helps—but the middle passenger ought to wear a hardhat because the dome light is directly above. Windows are big, so the driver enjoys excellent vision all around.

The selector dial for driveline settings is within easy reach of the driver’s right hand low on the instrument panel. Convenient dials are used to set temperatures for the PRO-4X’s standard dual-zone climate system; all else is managed by buttons clustered in between them. Outboard passengers have an A- or B-pillar handgrip for when terrain might get rough and bumpy, or to assist entry because step-in is a little high.

Quick Spin: 2020 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

Frontier Taligate

The PRO-4X comes only as a crew cab with the short bed; maximum payload capacity is 1020 pounds.

A big glove-box lid belies a narrow box behind it. There’s not much space in the console box, and the only seat-back pouch is on the back of the driver’s seat. There is a pull-down central armrest in back, but cup holders pop out of the back of the console. All four doors have decent storage pockets with bottle holders. Rear seat backs fold flat, and the cushions fold up to reveal storage bins.

In terms of features and appointments, the Frontier is pretty basic. Hard plastic is everywhere, and little effort is made to hide the fact that it’s plastic. The only soft stuff is on the seats, steering-wheel and shifter wraps, console-box lid, and as little of the door armrests as Nissan could get away with. Displays for things like the climate-system temperature readouts and odometer are old-school stick-figure numerals on a lighted orange background. The touchscreen for audio and navigation is small, and controls are simple. Menus? This is a compact pickup truck, not a restaurant. The tailgate is not damped—let it go and it just drops with a clunk.

Despite of its cost, perhaps this is appropriate for the PRO-4X’s image. It is supposed to be the model for rugged, outdoorsy Nissan buyers whose idea of a good time is jeux avec Frontières (you’re welcome, Peter Gabriel fans). Oddly, then, there is some charm in all this—and it will probably disappear when an all-new model comes around.

Forgotten Concept: Nissan Alpha-T

2020 Nissan Frontier

The 2020 model year is set to be the last for this long-running Nissan Frontier generation, but its new V6 engine will live on under the hood of the next-generation Frontier, which is slated to debut as a 2021 model.

Check out the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

2020 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X Crew Cab Gallery

Test Drive: 2020 BMW 840i Coupe

2020 BMW 840i Coupe

2020 BMW 840i Coupe in Aventurin Red Metallic (a $1950 option)

2015 Audi Q5

2020 BMW 840i Coupe

Class: Premium Sporty/Performance Car

Miles driven: 251

Fuel used: 8.9 gallons

CG Report Card
Room and Comfort B
Power and Performance B+
Fit and Finish A
Fuel Economy B+
Value B-
Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide’s impressions of the entire model lineup.
Big & Tall Comfort
Big Guy B
Tall Guy B
Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. “Big” rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, “Tall” rating based on 6’6″-tall male tester.
Drivetrain
Engine Specs 335-hp 3.0-liter
Engine Type Turbo 6-cyl
Transmission 8-speed automatic
Drive Wheels RWD

Real-world fuel economy: 28.0 mpg

Driving mix: 45% city, 65% highway

EPA-estimated fuel economy: 23/30/25 (city, highway, combined)

Fuel type: Premium gas recommended

Base price: $87,900 (not including $995 destination charge)

Options on test vehicle: Aventurin Red Metallic paint ($1950), Driving Assistance Package ($1100), Drivers Assistance Pro Package ($1700), M Sport Package ($4850), Comfort Seating Package ($500), 20-inch M V-spoke wheels with run-flat tires ($1300), Integral Active Steering ($1150)

Price as tested: $101,445

More 8-Series price and availability information

Quick Hits

The great: Classy cabin; confident 6-cylinder power with surprisingly good fuel economy for a high-dollar grand touring coupe

The good: About as agile as a big, heavy luxury coupe can get

The not so good: Rear seat is too small for most passengers–even kids; this “budget” 6-cylinder model can still be optioned past the 6-figure mark

John Biel

BMW planted a seed in 2019, and now the 8-Series seems to have reached full bloom in 2020.

The premium sporty/performance replacements for the 6-Series coupe and convertible launched in V8-and-all-wheel-drive M850i xDrive form. The new model year brings a Gran Coupe sedan, high-performance M and M Competition versions of all three body styles, and 6-cylinder 840i variants with the choice of rear- or all-wheel drive. Consumer Guide got its first taste of the 8-Series six in an 840i coupe, an $88,895 car (with delivery) that topped out at $101,445 with options.

BMW 840i Coupe

The 8-Series Coupe’s bodywork is sexy and sleek in the best grand-touring tradition, and despite the extra-rakish roofline, rearward visibility is better than in some class rivals.

Displacing 3.0 liters and rated at 335 horsepower, the turbocharged straight six is a familiar sight under the hoods of current BMWs. It is famously smooth and flexible in tandem with the fine standard 8-speed automatic transmission. With 368 lb-ft of torque that peaks at 1600 rpm and sticks around to 4500 revs, the 840i puts a shoulder into its work right away and keeps pushing for effortless acceleration. BMW states the 840i coupe will go from rest to 60 mph in 4.7 seconds—and buyers willing to shell out $2900 more for xDrive all-wheel drive can cut that to 4.4 seconds. Moving from the default “Comfort” drive mode to “Sport” or “Sport+” sharpens the throttle’s reflexes a little bit, and alters the transmission shift timing, but there’s already enough confident, quiet power in the base setting.

Quick Spin: 2019 Lexus LC 500

2020 BMW 840i Coupe

Our test vehicle came outfitted with “Cognac Extended Merino Leather,” a no-cost option that added to the regal interior ambiance. Seats are long-haul comfortable but they’re set low, so entry and exit is a “drop-in/climb-out” affair.

As for fuel economy, the EPA figures the rear-drive 840i for 23 mpg in the city, 30 mpg on the highway, and 25 in mixed driving. This driver’s limited test—68 miles; 35 percent city-type operation—averaged 25.7 mpg, but CGers’ aggregate mileage crested 28 mpg.

All 8-Series cars share a basic platform, even if that other “coupe” in the family is 9.1 inches longer (on a 7.9-inch-longer wheelbase), 1.4 inches wider, and 2.3 inches taller than its 2-door sibling. That includes aluminum-member multilink independent suspensions at either end.

Test Drive: 2019 BMW M850i Convertible

2020 BMW 840i Coupe

The center console is home to drive-mode buttons, an electronic parking brake, and the control knob for the iDrive  interface. Climate controls are fairly straightforward, and the extra-wide infotainment screen is a plus.

While too big and too heavy—listed curb weight is 3933 pounds—to deliver sports-car agility, the 840i nonetheless responds alertly to steering inputs, a sensation that comes up a notch in the Sport settings. Also on hand to help is rear-wheel Integral Active Steering, included with xDrive but an $1150 option that was added to our test car. An M Sport differential is included to aid traction. Body motion is well controlled in lane changes and cornering. Meanwhile, the suspension steps smartly over road imperfections, recognizing their presence but denying them the opportunity to disrupt cabin calm. Coasting along on the highway, even an overworked urban expressway, the touring is grand.

Test Drive: 2019 Mercedes-Benz AMG CLS53

2020 BMW 840i Coupe

There’s a respectable 14.8 cubic feet of cargo space in the 8-Series coupe’s trunk, although the aperture is a bit on the small side.

The 2-door models in the 8-Series range are effectively 2+2s with a back seat that’s better suited for additional cargo space than it is for more companionship. A sharply receding roofline and rear seat cushions that can nearly touch the front seats see to that. (No adult—probably no person—could have sat behind this 5-foot-10.5-inch reviewer where he had the driver’s seat set.) The fortunate two up front are privy to good legroom on comfortable, cosseting heated Merino-leather seats with cushion extenders. Rear roof pillars are commendably thin, and help to maximize over-the-shoulder vision for the driver. Slope-roof coupe designs sometimes result in mail-slot rear-window views, but the 840i’s rear aspect is a bit more open than most.

Regardless of body style, 8s have the same instrument panel. Controls start with “Live Cockpit Professional,” BMW’s combination of a 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster and a 10.25-inch centered screen for the iDrive 7.0 infotainment system, including navigation. Voice commands, touchscreen contact, or remote control from a dial on the console work the system. While the current iDrive is more intuitive to use than earlier iterations were, it remains somewhat complicated, and the remote is a distraction when used on the go. Connectivity needs are treated with standard Apple CarPlay smartphone compatibility, wireless charging, and a Wi-Fi hotspot are included, too.

Test Drive: 2019 Land Rover Range Rover Sport SVR

2020 BMW 840i Coupe

The 840i’s gutsy 335-hp 6-cylinder feels even stronger than its horsepower rating would suggest, and delivered fine fuel economy in our tests. Even with the optional 20-inch wheels on run-flat tires, the ride was commendably absorbent.

Additional built-in luxuries are a heated steering wheel and door armrests, 14-way power-adjustable front seats, remote engine start, keyless entry and starting, Harman Kardon surround-sound audio, and satellite radio. Connected Package Pro adds real-time traffic information and BMW Remote Services telematics. The Active Guard system includes safe-driving aids such as front-collision warning and city-collision mitigation, but blind-spot detection and lane-departure warning are part of the Driving Assistance Package option that contributed $1100 to the total cost of the test car.

Interior storage options include a large glove box and a console box with a split-top lid that is hinged at the sides to allow entry from either seating position. There are long door pockets and twin covered cup holders in the console. Trunk space is serviceable, certainly roomy enough for weekend-getaway luggage, and the 60/40 rear seats fold flat to extend the load floor.

The BMW 840i is a sophisticated yet still fun-to-drive expression of a premium sports coupe, and further evidence of how the 8-Series has blossomed.

Garage Space: 25 Late-Model Collectible Cars

BMW 840i Coupe

Plus-size luxury/sport coupes are among the more decadent vehicles around, but the BMW 840i Coupe delivers satisfying acceleration AND decent fuel economy. And if you’re careful with options, you can stay under six figures.

Check out the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast

BMW 840i Coupe

2020 BMW 840i Coupe